Wikia

TARDIS Index File

Talk:Moonbase

42,277articles in progress

Back to page

Are they the same?Edit

What's the basis for claiming the moonbase in The Moonbase and the one in Seeds of Death are the same? They don't look anything alike and seem to have different functionalities. CzechOut | 18:57, 23 April 2009 (UTC)

Logic would dictate that they're both bases, on the moon and they're both called 'moonbase'. So do we either have two articles discussing the two moonbases (there's also another one mentioned I think in Eternity Weeps). Or do we have this article as a general 'Moonbase' article which has info about the various moonbases that have been called 'moonbase' (that were bases on Earth's moon). --Tangerineduel 15:25, 24 April 2009 (UTC)
I'd choose the latter, but the question for me is whether the original editor who made this association was right. Is there some little snippet of, I dunno, a Gary Russell continuity-fest that suggests the two are the same? It's possible, just given the relative proximity of the two serials in the timeline. Still, if we can't find a definitive link between the two, then we should convert the article to a general one about "moonbases" and give the two instances as examples of moonbases. CzechOut | 18:26, 24 April 2009 (UTC)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki